Investment - Articles - How ESG scores conflict with climate investing


A new study from Scientific Beta, entitled "Green Dilution: How ESG Scores Conflict with Climate Investing", shows that the successive growth of ESG and climate investing has led practitioners to promote strategies that aim to fulfil both higher ESG scores and lower carbon emissions, without considering the potential trade-off between these two dimensions.

 The study, co-authored by Noël Amenc, Felix Goltz, and Antoine Naly, shows that green dilution is pervasive, regardless of which ESG scores are targeted as objectives, substantial, with an average of 92% across portfolios, and robust across several alternative specifications. A 92% green dilution means that 92% of the carbon intensity reduction investors could have reached by solely weighting stocks to minimise carbon intensity is lost when adding ESG scores as a partial weight determinant. Only 8% of the carbon reduction objective survived the inclusion of ESG scores in portfolio weighting schemes.

 Overall, the study provides clear evidence against the quantitative mixing of ESG and carbon scores in equity portfolio weighting schemes, which comes at great carbon cost for green investors. Conversely, the study provides evidence in favour of the exclusionary approach to ESG objectives, to best accommodate multiple non-financial and unrelated objectives.

 Commenting on the study, Felix Goltz, co-author, and Research Director at Scientific Beta, said, "The carbon intensity reduction of green portfolios can effectively be cancelled out by adding ESG objectives. On average, social and governance scores more than completely reversed the carbon reduction objective. If you add more unrelated criteria, you are not going to perform well on all of them, so you have to think about your priorities. By adding too many you are losing the focus. If you are interested in reducing the carbon intensity of your portfolio, you are going to get that only by focusing on the carbon intensity, otherwise you are very quickly going to be getting green dilution."

 The Scientific Beta study can be accessed here:

 Green Dilution: How ESG Scores Conflict with Climate Investing, Scientific Beta Publication, June 2023

Back to Index


Similar News to this Story

Inheritance Tax raises almost GBP6 billion in 8 months
December’s update from HMRC shows that Inheritance Tax (IHT) receipts reached £5.7 billion through the first two-thirds of this financial year (April
PIC completes first Mosaic buyin with GCB Pension Fund
Pension Insurance Corporation plc (“PIC”) has concluded its first full scheme buy-in within Mosaic, PIC’s streamlined service for pension schemes with
Airways Pension Scheme complete longevity hedge with MetLife
The Trustees of the Airways Pension Scheme (“the Scheme”), Metropolitan Tower Life Insurance Company, a subsidiary of MetLife, Inc., (“MetLife”) and Z

Site Search

Exact   Any  

Latest Actuarial Jobs

Actuarial Login

Email
Password
 Jobseeker    Client
Reminder Logon

APA Sponsors

Actuarial Jobs & News Feeds

Jobs RSS News RSS

WikiActuary

Be the first to contribute to our definitive actuarial reference forum. Built by actuaries for actuaries.